How Gold and Silver Are Traded By Different Investor Types
I’ve been a gold and silver guy for a long time. I like the metals. I like owning the metals. I like the idea of having something tangible that doesn’t depend on somebody else’s promise to pay me back.
And after holding a significant amount of physical gold and silver for roughly seven years, I did something that, judging by a few reactions online, may have violated the sacred oath of precious-metals ownership.
I sold some.
Then I sold the rest.
Apparently, once you buy gold and silver, you’re supposed to love them, cherish them, and promise never to part with them, no matter what the charts look like. I must have missed that part of the paperwork.
The funny thing is that I haven’t stopped liking precious metals. I still believe there can be tremendous opportunities in gold and silver over time. I just don’t believe liking something is a sufficient reason to hold it while the evidence changes.
And that, I’ve discovered, can be an unpopular thing to say.
First, here’s what actually happened
I began building my physical-metals position in 2019 and added during the market turmoil in 2020. These weren’t positions I flipped on a Friday because I got bored after lunch. I held them for years.
On January 15, 2026, I discussed silver’s strong uptrend and a technical target near $106.25. Momentum was strong, volume was picking up, and the move was exciting. I was bullish on the trend. I also explained that an advance toward that target could bring a final rush of buyers—the kind of move where people stop asking what an asset is worth and start asking whether they’ll be able to buy it before it goes higher again.
I said I was looking at trimming my physical holdings as silver moved into that area. Not because I suddenly hated silver, but because a rapid advance changes the balance between potential reward and the amount of profit you’re risking by continuing to hold.
On January 28, I sold 40% of my physical gold and silver. I told my members what I’d done. On February 12, after reassessing the charts and the price action, I sold the remaining 60% and explained that decision too.
Between those dates the markets were anything but calm. Silver had experienced an extraordinary run and an equally extraordinary air pocket. In a subsequent interview, I said metals might bounce back—even push higher—before any larger correction developed. At that stage I still held part of my physical position. That mattered: the evidence was evolving, and so was my decision.
I didn’t know what would happen next. I still don’t get emails from the market announcing next Thursday’s top. I work from probabilities, price behavior, trend strength, and what I’m prepared to risk.
Selling in two stages wasn’t a declaration that I could predict the future. It was a decision to take gains and then respond to the evidence as it developed.
What happened when I told members
Before we get to the more theatrical reactions online, there’s the calmer side to this story. When I shared my January and February physical-metals decisions with TTT members, I explained what I was seeing and why I was acting. Members had questions. Some wondered whether silver might bounce. Others asked about reentry and whether I’d use ETFs the next time around. That’s exactly the kind of discussion I want.
One member wrote:
“Chris, appreciate the update! Feels good to take profits.”
Another said:
“Chris, nothing wrong with using good risk management and taking profits.”
A third member acknowledged the other side of the decision:
“Yes, I accept I may miss out on a bounce back up but I’m happy with the good money I’ve made by locking in those gains.”
That last member also admitted having to rein in a little greed. I appreciated the honesty. I’ve been looking at charts for decades, and I still haven’t found a technical indicator that makes greed pack its bags and leave.
What I value about a serious investing community isn’t automatic agreement. It’s being able to share the research as conditions change, ask good questions, talk through the trade-offs, and disagree without turning every market opinion into a personal insult. These were my own physical holdings, not an instruction for everyone to sell theirs. Members could examine the reasoning and decide how, or whether, it applied to their own objectives.
I value the thousands of people who watch my free videos, too. But a video comment thread and an ongoing research conversation aren’t quite the same thing. One may give you a snapshot of a market call; the other gives us room to revisit the charts, the reasoning, and the next set of conditions.
The numbers—and what they do not prove
Using the historical spot closing prices supplied for those two dates, the estimated weighted-average spot benchmark for my 40% January 28 and 60% February 12 exits is approximately $5,105 per ounce for gold and $90.82 per ounce for silver.
For comparison, a historical spot-price series shows gold near $4,125 and silver near $57.47 on October 21, 2026. That’s approximately 19% lower for gold and 37% lower for silver than those estimated weighted benchmarks.
To be clear, those are comparisons of spot-price benchmarks—not what my dealer necessarily paid me for individual coins or bars. Physical transactions involve premiums and spreads, and the precise realized proceeds would require actual transaction records. Markets also differ a little depending on the quote source and close convention.
And here’s the more important point: I don’t need October’s prices to justify a decision I made in January or February. I had to make that decision with the information available then. A good process has to make sense before the outcome is known, not just after somebody gets to circle the chart and say, “See?!”
If metals had gone another 20% higher after I sold, I would have missed that move. I knew it was possible. That was a cost I was willing to accept. Taking profits does not come with a guarantee that you sold at the highest price anybody will ever pay.
Apparently, seven years is now a short-term trade
After discussing my outlook publicly, I read some of the comments. That was educational. Possibly more educational than I had planned.
One viewer wrote:
I had owned the physical metals since 2019 and added in 2020. If that’s a quick opportunity, I’d hate to see how long I’m expected to hold something to qualify as patient. Perhaps the position needs to graduate from university before I’m allowed to sell it.
That comment gets at something fascinating. People often celebrate buying an asset when nobody wants it. They celebrate having the conviction to sit through years of doubt. But when you actually sell after a major advance, some people see that as a lack of conviction.
Why? Buying is treated like loyalty. Selling can be treated like betrayal.
But the asset doesn’t know you own it. Gold doesn’t send me a thank-you card for being faithful. Silver doesn’t check how long I’ve held it before deciding whether to drop 20% in a week.
My investment account has a job to do. Its job is not to prove I’m the world’s most devoted precious-metals fan.
Sometimes the comment section is the chart of human emotion
Another viewer wrote:
I love the confidence. I wish the market would send me price targets with that much certainty.
Could silver eventually trade at a much higher price? Absolutely. I’ve discussed the possibility of much higher long-term metals prices myself. But “silver is going much higher someday” and “silver is a good purchase at this price today” are two different statements.
There’s a great deal of investing trouble hidden inside the word someday. Someday might arrive next quarter. Someday might arrive after a major decline. Someday might arrive after years of watching something else perform better. Nobody gets those years back.
A different commenter offered a much more substantive objection:
That’s a real issue worth discussing, not dismissing. Futures markets, ETFs, dealer premiums, physical ownership, and the availability of actual bars and coins are not interchangeable. If someone’s primary objective is to own metal outside the financial system, a paper-market chart cannot answer every question that matters to them.
But a difference between physical ownership and financial-market pricing doesn’t automatically make price trends irrelevant. If you’re evaluating the market value of an asset you might buy or sell, price still matters. You can disagree with how the price is formed and still have to live with what buyers will pay.
And then there was the viewer who wrote:
Maybe I did miss particular opportunities. I miss plenty. So does everybody else. There are thousands of securities, and I don’t own all the ones going up. If your standard is never missing a rally, investing is going to be a miserable hobby.
That’s an important distinction: missing one opportunity is not the same as making a bad decision. Neither is catching one rally proof that every subsequent decision will be good.
Why an investment opinion can feel like a personal insult
Here’s where the psychology gets interesting.
If you’ve spent years studying monetary policy, accumulating silver, talking with other metals investors, and waiting for a powerful breakout, your view can become much more than an opinion about a chart. It can become part of how you see the world—and part of how you see yourself.
Now imagine someone turns up with a chart and says, “The trend is weakening. I’m taking profits.”
You might hear a much louder message: Everything you’ve believed is wrong.
That’s not necessarily what was said. It’s certainly not what I mean. But when we feel personally invested in an outcome, a different market interpretation can trigger the same defensiveness as an attack on our judgment.
Jared Tendler writes about the mental game of trading in a way I appreciate: emotions don’t simply disappear because we know we should be disciplined. Fear, hope, regret, impatience, and the need to be right can all pressure our decisions. The work is recognizing those patterns before they take over the controls.
And believe me, gold bugs don’t have a monopoly on this behavior. I’ve seen technology investors defend a former market darling all the way down. I’ve seen traders chase sectors after the easy part of the move may already have happened. I’ve seen people refuse to exit a losing position because the moment they sell, they fear it will rocket higher without them.
I’ve felt versions of those pressures myself. The point isn’t to become a robot. The point is not to put those feelings in charge of the portfolio.
FOMO doesn’t stop when you buy
Everybody knows what fear of missing out looks like on the way up: silver starts running, your neighbor tells you what he’s made, the headlines get louder, and suddenly the price you’re paying seems less important than the fear that you’ll never get another chance.
But FOMO works when you’re deciding whether to sell, too.
What if I sell at $100 and it goes to $120? What if it goes to $200? What if there really is some extraordinary overnight event? What if the moment I take profits turns out to be the start of an even bigger rally?
Those are legitimate possibilities. I considered them. I even admitted in an interview that not holding much physical metal left me feeling somewhat exposed. I wasn’t pretending the choice was effortless.
But the opposite risks were legitimate as well. What if a parabolic advance reversed? What if my accumulated gains started disappearing? What if the asset went sideways for five or ten years while other strong trends came and went?
Investors often talk as if there must be a painless choice hidden somewhere. There isn’t. There are trade-offs. I decided which risks I was willing to carry.
If your gold is insurance, we’re having a different conversation
This is where I think many arguments about metals go off the rails.
If you own physical gold or silver as permanent monetary insurance, that is a different purpose from owning it as capital you expect to grow. You may be willing to hold that insurance through a big decline because you’re not judging it only by its market price. You may value having metal in your possession regardless of whether its quoted price falls next month.
I respect that. And I understand it.
But my substantial physical position was investment capital. I bought into a favorable longer-term opportunity, held through a major advance, and eventually concluded that I preferred to take the gains rather than keep all of that exposure through a potentially difficult period.
Neither decision has to be a universal rule for everybody else.
The trouble starts when we mix the two purposes. We tell ourselves the holding is permanent insurance when the price falls, then celebrate its annual return when it rises, then get angry if someone suggests reviewing the position. That’s quite a performance review system. The asset gets credit for the gains and an exemption from questions about the losses.
Choose the purpose first. Then judge the position by the job you actually gave it.
A strong story is not the same as a strong trend
I understand the big arguments for owning precious metals. Government debt, monetary instability, geopolitical shocks, inflation, physical supply, demand—these are serious subjects. Some can support a compelling long-term case for gold and silver.
But markets don’t have to follow the timetable of a compelling narrative.
Sometimes prices anticipate the news. Sometimes everybody already knows the story. Sometimes an asset falls when the headlines seem to say it should rise. And sometimes the best fundamental argument arrives just as the price action becomes the most dangerous.
That doesn’t mean fundamentals don’t matter. It means an investor still needs a way to decide what to do when the actual trend disagrees with the story.
I look at price action, trend, momentum, and how assets behave around important levels. I want evidence that buyers are still in control. When the trend deteriorates, I pay attention even if the long-term story remains attractive.
The market doesn’t award extra points because your explanation sounds convincing at a dinner party.
And please, watch more than the thumbnail
I’ve appeared in interviews where we discussed several possible outcomes: a rally could continue, a pullback could develop, the chart could break down, and I might change my position if the evidence changed. That’s a normal market discussion.
A title or thumbnail has maybe a few words to capture all that. Sometimes the dramatic possibility gets the headline. That’s how online attention works. It doesn’t mean an interviewer has done anything wrong, and it certainly doesn’t mean everybody who comments has skipped the actual conversation.
Still, if we react to five words without hearing the conditions behind them, we’re not evaluating an analysis. We’re reacting to a headline—and frequently filling in the missing details with what we already believe.
If someone says silver could fall sharply, that is not the same as saying it must fall tomorrow. If someone says gold could eventually reach dramatically higher prices, that is not a command to buy at any price today.
Those little words—could, if, until, unless—are doing a lot of work. They’re worth listening for.
I can love gold and still buy it back later
Here’s the part that gets overlooked when people decide I must have become a permanent metals bear.
If gold and silver stabilize, rebuild favorable price structures, and establish strong new trends, I can participate again. I might buy at a lower price. I might buy at a higher price. I don’t particularly care about winning an argument with my previous sell price.
I care about whether the next opportunity looks attractive based on the evidence then.
That’s also why I don’t need to predict the exact bottom or top. I can be early, late, or wrong. A false signal can cost money. Staying in cash can mean missing a rally. Selling physical metal and buying it back can involve real costs. There is no magical approach that removes those inconveniences.
What I don’t want is to let pride turn a position into a lifetime commitment that nobody ever consciously agreed to.
And I don’t want to spend the next several years trying to prove that an asset owes me another rally because I’ve been a loyal customer.
One final question before you polish your silver
I still like gold. I still like silver. I still enjoy talking about both. I have absolutely no objection to somebody holding a permanent stash for reasons different from mine.
What interests me is what happens when we stop asking whether an investment still serves its purpose and start defending it as if it were a member of the family.
Before you look at the next gold headline, silver forecast, AI stock, mining share, or hot ETF, ask yourself three questions:
- If I didn’t already own it, would I want to buy it today?
- Am I holding it because the current evidence supports my plan—or because I’d hate to watch it rise after I sold?
- If it moves sharply against me, do I know what I’ll do?
If you have clear answers, excellent. We don’t have to make the same decisions.
If you don’t, perhaps the next thing to buy isn’t another ounce of silver. It might be a little clarity.
Just don’t tell the comment section I said that.
Chris Vermeulen
Chief Investment Officer
TheTechnicalTraders.com
P.S. Book your free call with my team now! Pick a day and time here.
Disclaimer:
The content published on this website, including blog posts, videos, research articles, and commentary, is intended solely for informational and educational purposes and should not be construed as investment advice. Technical Traders Ltd. and its affiliates are not registered as investment advisers with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission or any state securities authority. The information provided is general in nature and is not tailored to the investment needs of any specific individual. Nothing published on this site constitutes a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any particular security, commodity, or financial instrument. The views expressed represent the opinions of the authors and are subject to change at any time without notice. Performance results discussed may include live trading outcomes and/or backtested or hypothetical data. Hypothetical results are inherently limited and do not reflect actual trading performance. No representation is made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those discussed. Past performance is not indicative of future results. All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Testimonials and user experiences presented may not be representative of others and do not guarantee future success. Some content may contain affiliate links or promotional material, from which we may earn compensation. This does not influence our content or editorial independence. By accessing this website or consuming its content, you acknowledge that you are solely responsible for your own financial decisions and agree to consult a licensed financial professional before acting on any information provided. If you don’t want to receive my help or these emails, please Unsubscribe
New from Chris Vermeulen
After the Rally.
When trusted investing rules stop protecting your wealth, retirement and lifestyle.
A poorly timed downturn early in retirement can permanently cut your sustainable income. Chris explains why buy-and-hold, dividend reliance and dollar-cost averaging fall short late in the cycle, and how disciplined cash rotation protects what you have built.
Print · Digital · Audio
Get the book on AmazonAlso by Chris
Asset Revesting
The core text: hold only assets rising in value, move to cash in downtrends, and keep building wealth in retirement. With Ashley Mulock.
View on AmazonTechnical Trading Mastery
Seven steps to win with logic. Market structure, trend, volatility, volume and his INNER-Market Analysis. Second edition.
View on AmazonThe Asset Revesting Library
A complete curriculum: the maths of drawdowns and sequence risk, institutional trend mechanics, and the cash and rotation rules that tie it together.
As an Amazon Associate, The Technical Traders may earn from qualifying purchases.
